Dr. Safa Blog
Unfiltered Psychiatrist Thoughts

What Is The Point?

The Evolutionary and Biological Bases of Human Struggles: Death, Isolation, Freedom, and Meaninglessness: How Evolution and Biology Shape Our Core Existential Concerns

Safa Rubaye, MD
October 17, 2024
why am I?

Have you ever felt overwhelmed by the burden of making a life-changing decision, or been gripped by the haunting thought of your own mortality? Have you experienced the pang of isolation even when surrounded by others or wrestled with the question, “What is the point of all this?”. As someone interested by the biological and evolutionary foundations of our inner worlds, I believe these existential struggles—freedom, death, isolation, and meaninglessness—are not just philosophical musings; they are echoes of our evolutionary past that continue to shape our minds and behaviors today.

Death: The Biological Imperative of Survival and the Fear of Non-Existence

Death is perhaps the most profound existential concern, deeply rooted in our biology and evolution. From an evolutionary perspective, the primary goal of any organism is to survive long enough to reproduce and pass on its genes. This drive is at the core of life itself, governing the behavior of every living thing from simple bacteria to complex mammals. For humans, this instinct to survive and propagate has been a fundamental force shaping our emotions, decisions, and social structures.

Our fear of death is not just a philosophical anxiety but a biological one, hardwired into our brains. Evolution has equipped us with a powerful survival instinct that compels us to avoid danger, seek safety, and protect ourselves and our offspring. The amygdala, a part of the brain associated with fear and threat detection, plays a critical role in this process, triggering the fight-or-flight response that has kept humans alive for millennia. But unlike other animals, humans are uniquely aware of their mortality, an awareness made possible by our advanced cognitive abilities.

This consciousness of death creates a paradox: while our biology drives us to survive, we are acutely aware that survival is ultimately temporary. This tension between the desire to live and the inevitability of death generates existential anxiety, influencing everything from personal behaviors to cultural practices. Religions, rituals, and even the quest for legacy through art, achievements, or progeny are all ways humans cope with the existential dread of mortality. The deep-seated fear of death is not just about personal loss but about the interruption of the biological imperative to pass on one's genes and contribute to the continuity of the species.

HealoVerse

Visit HealoVerse to learn more about how ketamine treatment and AI-empowered VR psychotherapy can help with depression, anxiety, PTSD, OCD, phobia, and pain.

Isolation: Belonging, Kin Selection, and the Struggle for Identity

Isolation and the deep human need for belonging are also rooted in evolutionary biology. Early humans were not the strongest or fastest creatures, but they thrived because of their ability to form close-knit groups, relying on social bonds for protection, cooperation, and mutual support. From an evolutionary standpoint, being part of a group was critical for survival, enhancing access to resources, safety from predators, and success in raising offspring.

Kin selection, a key concept in evolutionary biology, explains how social bonds were particularly strong among relatives. By helping those who share our genes, such as siblings or offspring, we indirectly ensure the survival of our genetic material. This is why humans evolved strong inclinations toward caring for family members and close kin—our brains are wired to promote behaviors that increase the survival chances of our genetic lineage.

Beyond kin, the need to belong to a broader group—tribe, community, or society—also played a crucial role in our evolutionary history. Social cohesion offered safety in numbers, shared knowledge, and collective problem-solving, making belonging a fundamental human drive. The brain rewards social connections with neurotransmitters like oxytocin, which fosters feelings of trust, bonding, and security. At the same time, social rejection or isolation triggers the brain’s pain centers, showing how deeply we are biologically wired to avoid loneliness and seek inclusion.

Isolation, however, is not just about physical separation from others; it also involves the struggle with identity. Humans, with their complex brains, developed not only a sense of self but also the need to see themselves as valuable within a social context. This is why identity—our sense of who we are within our family, culture, and society—matters so deeply. It helps us understand our place in the group, reinforcing a sense of belonging and purpose. Yet, the complexity of human identity also means we are often caught in conflicts between our individual desires and social expectations, leading to feelings of disconnection even in the midst of social interaction.

Ad: Visit HealoVerse to explore the AI-powered VR Psychotherapy in combination with at-home ketamine

Freedom and Responsibility: The Double-Edged Sword of Human Choice

Freedom, or the ability to make choices, is a distinctly human experience shaped by our evolved cognitive capabilities. The development of the prefrontal cortex, which allows for advanced planning, decision-making, and self-control, gave humans a significant survival advantage. This ability to consider multiple outcomes, delay gratification, and strategize set our species apart, enabling us to navigate complex social and environmental landscapes.

However, this freedom to choose comes with a psychological burden—responsibility. With each decision, there is the risk of making the wrong choice, leading to consequences that impact not just the individual but also their kin and social group. This constant weighing of options can create anxiety and a sense of existential guilt, as humans grapple with the awareness that their choices define their lives and influence those around them.

From an evolutionary perspective, the anxiety associated with choice serves an adaptive function, pushing us to think carefully about our actions and their long-term effects. Yet, this heightened self-awareness also makes us vulnerable to regret and the fear of missing out on alternative paths, turning the freedom that empowers us into a source of internal conflict. The biological roots of this tension are embedded in our need to optimize survival outcomes, balancing the benefits of choice with the risks of uncertainty.

4MEIA logo

Facing an Existential Crisis? Discover Clarity and Purpose with 4MEIA’s Personalized Assessment!

Start Here

Meaninglessness: The Evolved Quest for Purpose in a Complex World

Humans are wired to seek meaning and purpose, a drive that has deep evolutionary roots. In ancestral environments, the purpose was often clear: survive, protect kin, reproduce, and contribute to the group’s welfare. These tasks were directly tied to the continuation of the species, providing a sense of direction and coherence. Our brains, evolved to detect patterns and make sense of the world, were naturally drawn to actions that had clear goals and outcomes.

However, as societies became more complex, the tasks of survival became less immediate and more abstract, leading to a broader existential search for meaning. Modern humans, equipped with a highly developed prefrontal cortex, are capable of pondering questions far beyond the basic needs of survival. This advanced cognitive capacity pushes us to ask, “Why am I here?” and “What is the point?”—questions that are difficult to answer in a world where purpose is not always straightforward.

The struggle with meaninglessness is, therefore, a reflection of an evolved mind that craves coherence and purpose but often finds itself at odds with the ambiguous nature of modern life. This ongoing quest for significance is not just a psychological pursuit but a biological drive, rooted in the same brain functions that helped our ancestors navigate and make sense of a complex world.

Conclusion

The struggles with death, isolation, freedom, and meaninglessness are not merely abstract concepts; they are deeply woven into the biological and evolutionary fabric of human existence. These existential concerns reflect the ancient forces that have shaped our brains and behaviors, linking us to the survival imperatives that have driven humanity for millennia. Understanding these struggles through an evolutionary lens allows us to see them not as personal flaws or cultural quirks, but as profound, shared aspects of the human journey.

Safa Rubaye, MD
A psychiatrist, artist, entrepreneur, and educator who is committed to advancing mental health care through expertise, leadership, and ongoing learning. Passionate about improving lives through compassionate, evidence-based psychiatry.

This article is meant to provide general information and should not replace professional medical advice. Always consult your doctor to discuss the potential advantages and disadvantages of any treatment.

Related Articles

HealoVerse: affordable at home ketamine with VR psychotherapy

Sign Up for A

Free Consult

Visit HealoVerse to learn more about how ketamine treatment and VR psychotherapy can help with depression, anxiety, PTSD, OCD, phobia, and pain.

New Articles